Stupid People (involving fat testing children)

caseywhitcher

New member
This following article is so backwards, this lady is complaining that by testing the fat of her children they are being convinced to go on unhealthy diets, so.. rather than lobying to have health education and proper nutrition taught to students, she's lobying to have their fitness not evaluated, that should keep them healthy!



Does your school use calipers to measure your child's body fat?

In the September, 1993 issue of our newsletter, Working Together, ANAD reported on the practice in schools of using body fat measurement to determine the fitness of students. Apparently, not much has changed since then.

The fat calipers/skin fold test was actually developed for use with triathletes, 25 years of age or older, according to the American College of Sports Medicine in Indianapolis. The problem is that, for many years, this measurement has been used by school districts around the country to measure children in high schools, junior highs, and even grade schools. The result is that youngsters, who should be provided with adequate nutrition for their growing bodies, are instead going on diets because they think they are fat!

ANAD Resource person and a concerned mother, Patti Bahnick, is doing something about this. When Patti's nine-year-old daughter told her about the fat testing that had been administered nine months earlier, her daughter had already begun to eliminate breakfast, bedtime snacks, and a significant portion of lunches and dinners from her diet. After discovering how common this reaction to the fat testing was among her daughter's classmates, Patti consulted with ANAD President, Vivian Meehan, and did some additional research on the subject. Armed with that research, she was able to convince officials in her own school district to eliminate fat testing. As PTA president of her local school, Patti presented her research at the Illinois state PTA convention, where a resolution was passed pledging to work toward the elimination of fat caliper testing throughout the state.

In addition to working toward implementation of the resolution at the state level, Patti, with ANAD's help, is seeking to present the same resolution for the consideration of the national PTA at its convention in June, 2001. In order to do so, she is required to present adequate and substantial documentation as to the use of fat testing in schools in all 50 states.

You can help! If you have information that the fat calipers/skin fold test or other fat testing is being used in your school, please obtain documentation as to what testing is being done and its repercussions on the students in your district. Specify grade levels or student age and type of fat testing done. If your school district has eliminated fat testing, please send documentation on why this was done. To get additional information on this issue, contact ANAD or e-mail Patti at [email protected]. You can also check out Patti's website, www.FatTestingStories.org.
 
caseywhitcher said:
The result is that youngsters, who should be provided with adequate nutrition for their growing bodies, are instead going on diets because they think they are fat!

This is completely inappropriate. Children are not even remotely responsible enough to handle this kind of information. It is the parents' responsibility to encourage a healthy diet and activity level for their children. Schools should not disseminate this kind of information to children. It will only lead to more social problems.

Besides, bodyfat is NOT an indicator of physical fitness. I could be at 8%, a resonably lean level, and be in terrible cardiovascular condition, especially if all I do is anaerobic activities (e.g., weightlifting).
 
i had that shit done to me when i was in middle school, and they still use those calipers on wrestlers at my high school. I think i had a really high amount of bodyfat at the time.
 
kids need lots of chow if you want them to grow
soon we will have a nation of short malnurished adults
with realy low body fat kinda like ethiopia
remember children at puberty are on bulking cycle from nature
you wouldnt sstarve during your cycle so dant starve your kids
 
Schools should stick to teaching, and stop trying to be parents. I have six children, and we homeschool...BUT, if one of them ever came home from a public school with this kind of "information," I'd probably go ballistic...

Does the school know the background of each kid? Do they know who's hypoglycemic or diabetic or hypothyroid? Do they know how to "figure in" those things when telling a kid what their bf% is? Or do they just handout figures to kids? Do the kids then start taunting the ones who are already overweight ("Hah, I'll bet Joey's 90%!!!") Do they know what girls are already candidates for bulemia or anorexia? Do they let them know that there are ethnic differences, too?

I agree that kids today are fat, period. The amount of sugar and candy and carbo-fat crap that is thrown at them - by schools, at parties, and in their own homes -is out of control. The amount of time they spend glued in front of a TV or video game or game boy is out of control. BUT, it is up to PARENTS, not "The State" to raise children and make these decisions.

So the kids know their bf% from a pair of plastic calipers, eh? I wonder if they know their state capital and governor's name.....
 
damn when i have kids i am, just gonna start giving them fina with dbol ed until they turn 1year old. if its a girl i will give her winny and primo, if it is a guys i will give hime test, fina dbol and may be a little eq so they could eat a lot. by the age of two he should me shredded and rocking a muscle shirt on the streets.LMFO
 
guys i know the post i just made is very stupid but its 6am rite now and i am still at work. so i am pretty fucked up at this time.
 
Back
Top