NAIR
MuscleChemistry Registered Member
What are every ones general feelings on this? I don’t think much more is gayer than watching a shredded bodybuilder prance around a stage to music like it’s a night club—especially when they sing along to the lyrics and wave their hands in a gesture aimed at ramping the crowed up. To me, it’s pure nonsense; not much can be measured during these routines, they seem to be for entertainment purposes only. Many people claim that these “performances” are artistic! Imagine that, art! So I guess one of my questions is, do you find the routines entertaining and worth having in the show?
My second question relates to the overall integrity and objectivity of the sport. There’s no escaping the element of value judgments, or subjectivity, when it comes to scoring the competitors. That’s why, I think, they got rid of that as a scoring round. But do we really need to see Kai Greene in pink panties upside down doing splits after performing a double summersault? Does this best represent bodybuilding among a general audience? Or does it undermine the objective aim of the sport? It seems, to me, the best part of a show is when competitors line up to be compared. Also of value is pre-judging individual callouts of traditional posses; Together, the components of a show demonstrate the more objective side of the sport and present a level of seriousness or professionalism that you could find in other sports.
In short, I guess I’m arguing for ending individual posing routines. I believe they undermine bodybuilding—besides posing, they dance and lip sync to music, that in the end, looks like a bad audition of America’s Got Talent.
Please share your thoughts.
My second question relates to the overall integrity and objectivity of the sport. There’s no escaping the element of value judgments, or subjectivity, when it comes to scoring the competitors. That’s why, I think, they got rid of that as a scoring round. But do we really need to see Kai Greene in pink panties upside down doing splits after performing a double summersault? Does this best represent bodybuilding among a general audience? Or does it undermine the objective aim of the sport? It seems, to me, the best part of a show is when competitors line up to be compared. Also of value is pre-judging individual callouts of traditional posses; Together, the components of a show demonstrate the more objective side of the sport and present a level of seriousness or professionalism that you could find in other sports.
In short, I guess I’m arguing for ending individual posing routines. I believe they undermine bodybuilding—besides posing, they dance and lip sync to music, that in the end, looks like a bad audition of America’s Got Talent.
Please share your thoughts.








