Tag: Olympic Lifting
CrossFit vs Bodybuilding vs Powerlifting – Which One Should You Be Doing?
Choose Between The Three Heavyweights: Crossfit vs Bodybuilding vs Powerlifting
A person has many options to choose from when they decide they need to work on their health and fitness. Bodybuilding and powerlifting are relatively old sports as compared to CrossFit which has earned a loyal following and is spreading like wildfire.
While you could be the jack of all trades and can do CrossFit, bodybuilding, and powerlifting, you won’t see much progression in any of them. Choosing one sport and sticking with it will get you better results and mastery over it.
If you’re about to start your fitness journey or are thinking of making a switch between the sports, this article will help you learn more about the three sports. All the three sports have fundamentally different purposes and you need to choose the one which matches your goals.
CrossFit
If you’re someone who is into functional movements, CrossFit is the right fit for you. CrossFit is a high-intensity training program which helps people of all sizes and shapes build strength and conditioning.
According to CrossFit’s official website, “CrossFit contends that a person is as fit as they are proficient in each of ten general physical skills: cardiovascular/respiratory endurance, stamina, strength, flexibility, power, speed, agility, balance, coordination, and accuracy.”
CrossFit is different from bodybuilding and powerlifting as it is more accepting and encouraging. In CrossFit people usually workout in groups and follow a WOD (workout of the day). CrossFit gyms are radically different from commercial gyms as they don’t have any ellipticals, treadmills or weight training machines.
Bodybuilding
The main purpose of bodybuilding is to build muscle mass. Bodybuilders undergo high-intensity resistance training to build muscle and conditioning. If you’re a fan of the muscle aesthetics, bodybuilding is for you.
Bodybuilding first came into the limelight when Arnold Schwarzenegger, a 7X Mr. Olympia, made his Hollywood debut. Bodybuilding is the art of sculpting your body. You can work on your body and bring up your lagging muscle groups.
Bodybuilding primarily deals with building muscle mass and strength. As compared to CrossFit and powerlifting, bodybuilding is the most popular sport and you have a gym with weight lifting and cardio equipment on almost every block.
Powerlifting
Powerlifting is a test of strength and deals with lifting heavy weights on the three compound movements the bench press, deadlifts, and squats. Many people confuse powerlifting with strongman and Olympic lifting.
While powerlifting consists of the three compound movements, strongman is a wide-ranging sport. Strongman competitions challenge your strength and endurance and include events like log presses, truck pulling, keg lifts, etc.
Olympic lifting or weightlifting, on the other hand, consists of two lifts, snatch and clean and jerks. Snatch and clean and jerk are exercises you might have seen athletes perform during the Olympic games.
The main focus of powerlifting is to get stronger and lift heavier weights. A competitive powerlifter is always training to beat his own PR. If you have a knack for lifting heavy weights and enjoy doing it, powerlifting is the sport for you.
While all the three sports have different purposes, all of them require discipline in the form of training, nutrition and recovery.
Which of these three sports do you follow? Let us know in the comments below. Also, be sure to follow Generation Iron on Facebook and Twitter.
Master The Power Snatch and Watch Your Gains Skyrocket!
Developing Max Power
For many athletes and sportspeople, being powerful is absolutely crucial and can prove to be the difference between success and failure. This article will break down one of the greatest power-based exercises that can be performed for athletic development – the power snatch.
The Benefits of the Power Snatch
The power snatch is an exercise that is typically performed by Olympic weightlifters looking to improve their snatch performance. However, nowadays Olympic lifting is being performed more frequently by athletes from other sports as it is a method for increasing overall power output (1).
There are a number of specific benefits associated with the power snatch and therefore, for any individuals looking to improve power, it is worthwhile considering incorporating the power snatch into their training.
Bar Height
In the power snatch, it is not necessary to drop down into a squat in order to catch the bar. As a result of this, the bar must be pulled higher and with more power to allow it to be caught in a more upright position. Those who particularly struggle with final phase of the snatch or with the high pull will find this exercise to be of great benefit and it may improve their overall snatching ability.
Second and Third Pull Power
In a similar vein, the power snatch is an excellent developer of the second and third pull. The power snatch forces the lifter to pull maximally and “throw” the bar overhead. With a full snatch, dropping down quickly and deeply into a squat can compensate for a poor or inefficient pull.
Being capable of pulling powerfully and extending quickly through the hips will cause the bar to accelerate faster and facilitate a more efficient snatch (2). Therefore, practicing the power snatch regularly and improving one’s rate of force development will help to accelerate the bar to a greater extent and improve overall snatch performance.
Learning the Snatch
The snatch is a highly technical lift that takes time to learn properly – it is very important that time is taken and progress is gradual. Typically, coaches will start with the block or hang power snatch so that the individual can begin to learn the movement patterns and requirements for the snatch. Once this has been established, they can then be progressed to the floor. When pulling from the floor, a specific emphasis should be placed on developing both the 1st and 2nd pull (3).
The power snatch tends to be slightly easier to instruct than the full snatch due to the fact that the barbell can be caught in high and there is no need to drop into the overhead squat position. Once the power snatch has been perfected, then the overhead squat position can be taught through exercises. such as snatch balance, to gradually advance them to the point where they are eventually ready to perform a full snatch.
Snatching with Limited Mobility
Snatching with poor mobility is a recipe for disaster. Every single joint must be utilized during the snatch and must therefore be supple and be capable of moving through a great range of motion (4). For every serious lifter mobility should be a priority and should be worked on frequently.
However, for those who have restricted mobility, performing the power snatch is recommended. The full snatch is a lot more demanding on the joints as they are required to move through a larger range than the power snatch.
Increased Technical Training
For the Olympic Lifter, it’s unwise to practice heavy lifts with every session. With any type of physical training, it’s essential to program in a tapering period to allow for recovery.
Regularly performing technique-focused power snatches with moderate loads will not be overly taxing on the body and can therefore be performed very regularly without impacting the recovery process. Additionally, this may refine technique, enhance power and therefore improve one’s overall snatching ability.
How To Power Snatch
As mentioned, the power snatch differs from a full snatch in during the power snatch the bar is caught relatively high and a deep squat is not required. The full snatch involves driving the bar up and overhead but then rapidly dropping into a deep squat in order to catch the bar.
The main benefit of the power snatch is that, because the bar must be caught high, the lifter must generate maximal power in order to get the bar directly overhead and establish a strong and stable overhead position.
The following number of points run through how to appropriately and effectively complete a power snatch.
1) Assume the snatch position
Feet slightly wider than hips, toes pointed out, bar in close proximity to the shins, gripping the bar with straight arms and hands wider than shoulders. The way in which a lifter sets up is determined by their physical attributes and therefore, there is not a “universal” snatching position.
2) Perform a standard snatch pull (first, second and third pull)
This involves initially lifting the bar from the floor, bringing the bar up to the thighs, extending powerfully through the hips and pulling aggressively upward on the bar.
3) Catch the bar high
Look to “catch” the bar high and do not not allow it to push the body down into a deep squat – the lifter should not drop beyond parallel with the floor. Catching high will ensure that maximal power is produced during the pulls and lead to an efficient turnover and strong overhead position (5).
When performing a power snatch, it is essential that the lifter does not change anything about their snatch technique or adjust their mechanics to allow them to complete the lift. For example, a common error is to jump the legs out wide when catching the bar overhead to give them an advantage and prevent them from dropping too deep.
Adjusting movement patterns and mechanics for the power snatch may cause movement problems with the full snatch. Therefore, if movement begins to break down or inconsistencies begin to creep in with the power snatch, consider reducing the weight on the bar so that proper movement is restored.
Power Snatch Programming
Power snatches can be incorporated into many different training regimes but should only be included if it aligns with the individuals goals and targets. If a lifters goal is to improve their snatching ability, then it would make a great deal of sense to program in regular power snatches to improve their bar speed and pulling power.
It may be the case that an individual is already efficient at the power snatch, if this is the case, it would be worthwhile spending a greater amount of time on the full snatch to allow them to become more accustomed to handling heavier loads.
Testing a lifters one rep max can be beneficial for consequent programming to ensure that the correct weight and intensity are prescribed (6).
For developing bar speed and technique, it is recommended to perform 1-3 repetitions using 50-75% of the lifters full snatch 1 rep max.
For developing strength speed and for lighter training days, it is recommended to perform 1-2 repetitions using 70-85% of the lifters full snatch 1 rep max.
While improving the power snatch can certainly be beneficial, it should not be more important than improving the full snatch. Therefore, it is worthwhile assessing one’s full snatch regularly and look to pinpoint weak areas that can be improved.
Those who can power snatch a great deal of weight (more than 85% of their full snatch), may be stronger pullers already and therefore should focus more on the transition and getting under the bar quickly.
Conversely, those who can already rapidly drop under the bar and catch, may be better suited to concentrating on the power snatch for a period of time in order to develop their power generation and technique.
Final Word
There is no denying that the power snatch is one of the best exercises that can be performed for developing speed and power. Therefore, this exercise is highly recommended, not only for Olympic lifters, but also for athletes, sportspeople and lifters looking to develop their overall power.
For more news and updates, follow Generation Iron on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.
References:
1-Hackett, Daniel; Davies, Tim; Soomro, Najeebullah; Halaki, Mark (2016-7). “Olympic weightlifting training improves vertical jump height in sportspeople: a systematic review with meta-analysis”. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 50 (14): 865–872. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2015-094951. ISSN 1473-0480. PMID 26626268.
2-Hornsby, W. Guy; Gentles, Jeremy A.; MacDonald, Christopher J.; Mizuguchi, Satoshi; Ramsey, Michael W.; Stone, Michael H. (October 13, 2017). “Maximum Strength, Rate of Force Development, Jump Height, and Peak Power Alterations in Weightlifters across Five Months of Training”. Sports. 5 (4). doi:10.3390/sports5040078. ISSN 2075-4663. PMC 5969034. PMID 29910439.
3-Harbili, Erbil; Alptekin, Ahmet (May 1, 2014). “Comparative Kinematic Analysis of the Snatch Lifts in Elite Male Adolescent Weightlifters”. Journal of Sports Science & Medicine. 13 (2): 417–422. ISSN 1303-2968. PMC 3990899. PMID 24790499.
4-Gourgoulis, V.; Aggelousis, N.; Mavromatis, G.; Garas, A. (2000-8). “Three-dimensional kinematic analysis of the snatch of elite Greek weightlifters”. Journal of Sports Sciences. 18 (8): 643–652. doi:10.1080/02640410050082332. ISSN 0264-0414. PMID 10972413.
5-“Power Snatch Technique”. educ.jmu.edu.
6-Faigenbaum, Avery D.; McFarland, James E.; Herman, Robert; Naclerio, Fernando; Ratamess, Nicholas A.; Kang, Jie; Myer, Gregory D. (2012-2). “RELIABILITY OF THE ONE REPETITION-MAXIMUM POWER CLEAN TEST IN ADOLESCENT ATHLETES”. Journal of strength and conditioning research / National Strength & Conditioning Association. 26 (2): 432–437. doi:10.1519/JSC.0b013e318220db2c. ISSN 1064-8011. PMC 3561668. PMID 22233786.