Carbohydrates - Have we been lied to?

Bigfrog

New member
I think we have been totally mislead to about carbohydrates. Below you will find information I got from various websites off the net. If anyone knows more about this subject please post!!!

"How much do you know about the food you eat? Want to learn a little more? If so, answer true or false to the following questions.

1. Table sugar (sucrose) breaks down slower in the body than a slice of white bread.
__ True __ False



2. Fruit breaks down into sugar slower than white bread.
__ True __ False



3. Beans break down into sugar slower than instant rice.
__ True __ False


If you answered TRUE to all the above questions, congratulations! You certainly know a lot about the food you're eating. But if you weren't sure, or were surprised by the answers, there's something called the Glycemic Index you should learn about.

The basics
Up until a few years ago, health professionals believed that if a food was composed of complex carbohydrates (starches), it must break down into sugar more slowly in your body than food composed of simple carbohydrates (sugars). Through research, we have learned more about how foods affect blood glucose levels.

When you eat a slice of bread, the flour from the bread breaks down into sugar (glucose) in your body to provide you with energy. The same thing happens when you eat a piece of fruit, drink a glass of milk or eat a chocolate bar. Each of these foods contain a different kind of sugar. Fructose is a sugar in fruit, lactose is found in milk and sucrose is found in the chocolate bar. All of these sugars are broken down during digestion and provide you with energy.

The speed at which a food is able to increase a person's blood glucose levels is called the glycemic response. The glycemic response is influenced by many factors. Some factors may be the amount of food you eat, how the food is processed or the way the food is prepared. For example, pasta cooked 'al dente' (firm) is absorbed more slowly than pasta that is overcooked.

The glycemic index
The ranking of different foods based on their glycemic response was first studied by Dr. David Jenkins and colleagues at St. Michael's Hospital (Toronto). The research team conducted several experiments looking at the speed at which different foods affect blood glucose levels and compared the numbers to a slice of white bread. White bread is given the glycemic index value of 100. Foods that have a value less than 100 are converted into sugar more slowly than white bread. Foods that have a glycemic index value greater than 100 turn into sugar more quickly than white bread.

Other researchers have used glucose as the reference food, so glucose would have a value of 100. Today either glucose or white bread may be used as the reference food (if white bread = 100, then glucose = 140). Current values listed in this article should be divided by 1.4 to obtain the Glycemic Index(GI) of a food for which glucose = 100.

What the researchers found surprised them. Foods such as milk and fruit tend to have a lower glycemic index value than common starchy foods such as bread, rice, potatoes and breakfast cereals. Even sugar (sucrose) had a glycemic index of 83, lower than some starchy foods. The good news is foods that were previously avoided by people with diabetes can now be added to their diet in moderation.

Strategic eating
Selecting foods with a low glycemic index may help to manage your diabetes (see accompanying chart). Increasing the number of low glycemic index foods such as legumes, barley, pasta and whole grains (e.g., cracked wheat) in your meal plan may have real benefit in controlling blood glucose levels. Most low glycemic index foods offer more fibre and are low in fat, both of which are recommended in Health Canada's Guidelines for Healthy Eating, as well as the Canadian Diabetes Association's nutrition guidelines . High fibre foods also help lower your risk of heart disease. In fact, the Canadian Diabetes Association's Guidelines for the Nutritional Management of Diabetes in the New Millenium state that for every 10 gram increase in cereal fibre daily, the risk of heart disease decreases by 30 percent. By simply including a high fibre cereal such as 1-1/2 cups of oatmeal in your meal plan, you will have added an extra 10 grams of fibre.
As well as in****orating oatmeal or other high fibre cereals into your meal plan more often, here are a few more low glycemia index tips for healthy eating:

Prepare dishes with beans such as chili, soups, and salad.
Eat whole grain, pumpernickel and oat bran bread more often than white bread.
Eat fresh fruit. Fruits have a low glycemic index, so they break down into sugar slowly in your body. Canada's Food Guide recommends five to ten servings of fruits and vegetables every day. Enjoy a variety!
Eat parboiled, brown or white rice more often than instant rice.
Eat pasta, rice, yams, lima beans or baked potatoes more often than mashed, boiled or instant potatoes.
You should also remember that table sugar can produce a slower rise in blood glucose levels than potatoes, but it lacks the vitamins, minerals and fibre provided by the potato. Decisions on foods must be made on the basis of overall nutrition, as well as the impact on blood sugar.
Also, don't forget about the roles that fat and protein will play. Protein and fat with our meals can also slow down the absorption of carbohydrates, which are converted into sugars during digestion. Add fats in moderation to your foods and choose heart healthy fats such as non-hydrogenated margarine and vegetable oils.

The glycemic index is an average of the glycemic responses of many individuals. This index is fairly accurate and it is useful to determine your own blood glucose response to different foods and meal combinations. Regular self monitoring of blood glucose and good note-taking can help you determine your individual glycemic response to food.

Dana Whitham RD and Tasha Hamilton RD, CDE are dietitians at St. Michael's Hospital in Toronto." 1

1. http://www.diabetes.ca/Section_About/glycemic.asp
 
From my readings it seems that the Glycemic Index seems to vary. My knowledge on this is very limited. If you know more information on this topic pleas post! Below you will find a list of where to find the Glycemic Index, or just type Gylcemic Index on yahoo and browse for yourself. I posted this one because it was short. There are many detailed listings that can be found at the bottom of this page that list all the popular name brand products and their Glycemic Index. When I paste the below index it doesn't come out right so please click on the Glycemic link below to view it in its proper format: http://www.diabetesnet.com/diabetes_food_diet/glycemic_index.php

Glycemic Index
Cereals Snacks Pasta Beans
All Bran 51 chocolate bar 49 cheese tortellini 50 baked 44
Bran Buds + psyll 45 corn chips 72 fettucini 32 black beans, boiled 30
Bran Flakes 74 croissant 67 linguini 50 butter, boiled 33
Cheerios 74 doughnut 76 macaroni 46 cannellini beans 31
Corn Chex 83 graham crakers 74 spagh, 5 min boiled 33 garbanzo, boiled 34
Cornflakes 83 jelly beans 80 spagh, 15 min boiled 44 kidney, boiled 29
Cream of Wheat 66 Life Savers 70 spagh, prot enrich 28 kidney, canned 52
Frosted Flakes 55 oatmeal cookie 57 vermicelli 35 lentils, green, brown 30
Grapenuts 67 pizza, cheese & tom 60 Soups/Vegetables lima, boiled 32
Life 66 Pizza Hut, supreme 33 beets, canned 64 navy beans 38
muesli, natural 54 popcorn, light micro 55 black bean soup 64 pinto, boiled 39
Nutri-grain 66 potato chips 56 carrots, fresh, boil 49 red lentils, boiled 27
oatmeal, old fach 48 pound cake 54 corn, sweet 56 soy, boiled 16
Puffed Wheat 67 Power bars 58 green pea, soup 66 Breads
Raisin Bran 73 pretzels 83 green pea, frozen 47 bagel, plain 72
Rice Chex 89 saltine crakers 74 lima beans, frozen 32 baquette, Frnch 95
Shredded Wheat 67 shortbread cookies 64 parsnips 97 croissant 67
Special K 54 Snikers bar 41 peas, fresh, boil 48 dark rey 76
Total 76 strawberry jam 51 split pea soup w/ham 66 hamburger bun 61
Fruit vanilla wafers 77 tomato soup 38 muffins
apple 38 Wheat Thins 67 Drinks apple, cin 44
apricots 57 Crackers apple juice 40 blueberry 59
banana 56 graham 74 colas 65 oat & raisin 54
cantalope 65 rice cakes 80 Gatorade 78 pita 57
cherries 22 rye 68 grapefruit juice 48 pizza, cheese 60
dates 103 soda 72 orange juice 46 pumpernickel 49
grapefruit 25 Wheat Thins 67 pineapple juice 46 sourdough 54
grapes 46 Cereal Grains Milk Products rye 64
kiwi 52 barley 25 chocolate milk 35 white 70
mango 55 basmati white rice 58 custard 43 wheat 68
orange 43 bulgar 48 ice cream, van 60 Root Crops
papaya 58 couscous 65 ice milk, van 50 french fries 75
peach 42 cornmeal 68 skim milk 32 pot, new, boiled 59
pear 58 millet 71 soy milk 31 pot, red, baked 93
pineapple 66 Sugars tofu frozen dessert 115 pot, sweet 52
plums 39 fructose 22 whole milk 30 pot, white, boiled 63
prunes 15 honey 62 yogurt, fruit 36 pot, white, mash 70
raisins 64 maltose 105 yogurt, plain 14 yam 54
watermelon 72 table sugar 64

More complex and bigger list of GI indexes can be found below.

http://diabetes.about.com/library/mendosagi/ngilists.htm

http://diabetes.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http://optimalhealth.cia.com.au/gi17.html

http://diabetes.about.com/gi/dynami...p://optimalhealth.cia.com.au/GlycemicLoad.xls

http://diabetes.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http://www.gifoundation.com

http://diabetes.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http://www.glycemicindex.com

http://diabetes.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http://www.tanidesign.co.uk/

http://diabetes.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http://members.aol.com/nutrigenie/nggid48.html
 
Back
Top