Pure Protein Shakes vs Muscle Milk Shakes

[Presser]

Anyone ever drink these? Since I'm at B.J.'s every single Sunday for diapers and formula lol, I been grabbing myself cases of Muscle Milk Shakes (premade ready to drink) they as most of you know are only 20grams protein and they kill my stomach! So for the same price I been trying Pure Protein brand, these however do NOT hurt my stomach and have 30 grams of protein per shake and they're the same size pre made shakes.

Anyhow just bought 4 cases of these fuckers and was curious who has tried them and what they thought of them, cause i drink about 4 per day and sometimes they are watery and sometimes they are thick as fuck, regardless of how much i shake them before hand. I think that inconsistency is pretty fucked up!

Anyhow curious who knows anything about this brand

 

[Buffalo]

i've never been a fan of the premade shakes, seems like there is even more crap in there that I can't pronounce than a powder form.

BJ's doesn't have any powder? I know Costco sells Optimum and Muscle Pharm. Sams Club has a Muscle Tech brand that tastes like hell lol

 

[bigdaddyo1617]

i dont do pre made shakes and definite not muscle milk it me fat

 

[Erabus]

Had them both. I use them when im in a pinch. I do however prefer the Pure Protein over Muscle Milk due to the higher protein.

 

[Presser]

i've never been a fan of the premade shakes, seems like there is even more crap in there that I can't pronounce than a powder form.

BJ's doesn't have any powder? I know Costco sells Optimum and Muscle Pharm. Sams Club has a Muscle Tech brand that tastes like hell lol

Yeah they have powder proteins and I have and get loads of free protein powders jugs, it's just that I prefer premade at the moment, I've mixed thousands of shakes and I just figured I would start using premade for convenience.

 

[THASHIZ]

I like pure protein better.....more protein and less carbs.

 

[The Dude]

The longer they sit the more they thicken up. I know they add something in there to slow it down, but it still happens. I don't think there's anything wrong with them. As you know they probably aren't the best sources of protein (just because of additives and what not), but I've used them and I think they're fine. I wouldn't go near the Muscle Milk ones. I can just imagine how those would thrash my intestines, but I've tried the Pure Protein ones and they're alright. Better than the Isopure ones. Those are like shooting a CC of PGF2A right in my stomach. Aside from just blasting out my insides, those things make me physically sick.


The Dude Approved

 

[Presser]

yeah, i wonder why it is one hurts my stomach and one doesn't,

 

[cloudstrife1218]

It's an ingredient that you're body isn't fond of. Check over the two ingredient lists, and see what each uses. u allergic to anything?

 

[guardianactual]

MM has a lot more things in it than PS. MM has whey, for some reason un hydrolysed whey kills me where as casien doesn't. Could be that, but I doubt you have a problem w/ whey unless it's they specific form they use ? Also you did not specify flavor of both... Details bro details LMAO! Very well could be something they use that ur body does not like.

 

[RagingWhoreMoan]

Pure Protein is good stuff.

I use costco so for premade's I use Premiere Protein (30g)
I also use the On Whey Isolate sold at costco

Usually use premade during week and make my own during weekends

 

[Presser]

Pure Protein is good stuff.

I use costco so for premade's I use Premiere Protein (30g)
I also use the On Whey Isolate sold at costco

Usually use premade during week and make my own during weekends

exactly!

 

[IC Mauler]

Presser, I am like you I down about 3 of the Pure Protein a day and usually a RTD 51 post workout. I have had the same experience with them being thick and even chunky, I took them back and got different ones. I personally like the taste of the PP chocolate and even the vanilla.

 

[CH3NO2]

I cannot drink them. They make me shit within about 10 minutes.

The ONLY ones that are premade and don't fuck up my stomach are these. Bolthouse Farms - Protein Plus They are cold in in the produce section of my grocery store.

 

[big in vegas]

I must have an iron stomach because I've never had a problem with either one. The only thing that has ever gotten to me was MuscleTech's Nitro Tech

 

[goodness]

Any protein shake that is allowed to sit for a while will condensed down to the bottom. Im not sure what they use in them to help this but ive left a shake in the fridge before that I mixed from powder and it clumped within min. I like the taste of pure protein shakes though. They all have something weird about them though as for taste. Shit I cant afford them much lol. Just big bucket of powder for me.

 

[Presser]

I cannot drink them. They make me shit within about 10 minutes.

The ONLY ones that are premade and don't fuck up my stomach are these. Bolthouse Farms - Protein Plus They are cold in in the produce section of my grocery store.

Thats my favorite part in them making me wanna drop some friends off at the pool!